When it comes to fireplaces, there is a debate similar to the one about tortillas with or without onions, albeit with some distance. While some defend the idea that an open fireplace is always more effective at providing heat, others argue that closed fireplaces are much more efficient, clean, and safe. Which is better, an open or closed fireplace? Let’s see the pros and cons of these two systems, which basically differ in whether they have fireplace doors or not.
No one doubts that the image of a fireplace where logs are consumed while illuminating and emitting heat in the room is quite romantic. Watching the flames dance and hearing the crackling of the fire is relaxing and really beautiful. So the aesthetics play in favor of this type of open fireplace. But that’s all.
Open fireplaces are very inefficient
If we focus on the energy aspect, despite what many people think, a fireplace without a door is the worst way to heat up. With uncontrolled air entering, there is no way to regulate the temperature, and the fuel is consumed much more quickly. So it is expensive and ineffective.
Closed fireplaces, the best option
Although it is true that a closed fireplace emits slightly less heat than an open fire, it is also true that the amount of air entering the home can be easily controlled. Therefore, it can be adjusted to the specific needs of our ideal temperature, reducing fuel consumption. So if we measure the heat generating capacity of a fireplace with a single log, the combustion of the closed fireplace makes it much more efficient than if it were open. Obviously, closing the fireplace is the optimal option.
Additionally, the fireplace with a door is much cleaner and no odors are emitted inside the home. Everything is channeled towards the smoke outlet, eliminating the classic soot marks that always appear in open fireplaces.
Ventilation systems for closed fireplaces, allies!
Thanks to new ventilation systems for fireplaces, some systems make the heat return to the room, either by convection or induced by a fan. Together with the advantage that there is no risk of a spark jumping and igniting something, makes closing the fireplace with a glass ceramic door the best option.
Efficiency, safety, and comfort. These are the characteristics that make closed fireplaces the most recommended option. Also, having one at home is straightforward, as you only need to place a door on your fireplace to make it a more efficient system. And with the ceramic glass, you won’t give up the image of seeing the fire since it has very high transparency.